DID MARY HAVE OTHER CHILDREN?: Solving the Mystery of Brothers and Relatives Jesus

The Gospels mention the "brothers and sisters" of Jesus. So the answer is obvious - isn't it?Many Christians today assume that Mary and Joseph had an ordinary family life after Bethlehem, and that James, Joses, Simon and Judas were Jesus' younger half-brothers. Pastors preach it. Bestselling books repeat it. Hardly anyone pauses to ask where that assumption came from.Yet for the first fifteen centuries of Christian history, almost nobody believed it - and the reasons why are far more interesting, and far better documented, than either side of the modern debate tends to admit.In this thoroughly revised popular edition, Laurent Cleenewerck takes readers through every piece of evidence, in plain English, and lets them weigh it for themselves.A complete and even-handed review of all three positionsThis is not a one-sided tract. All three historic answers get a full, fair hearing in their strongest form: - The Helvidian view - the "brothers" were later children of Joseph and Mary- The Hieronymian view - they were cousins (the traditional Roman Catholic answer)- The Epiphanian view - they were Joseph's children from an earlier marriage (the ancient Eastern answer)Every significant argument is examined: the meaning of adelphos, the disputed "until" of Matthew 1:25, "firstborn son," Jesus entrusting Mary to John at the cross, Psalm 69, the silence of the Gospels - together with the witness of Hegesippus, Origen, Tertullian, Eusebius, Jerome, and Epiphanius, and the second-century Protevangelium of James.Rigorous scholarship, readable proseNothing is dodged and nothing is dumbed down. The author engages leading scholars by name - Richard Bauckham, John P. Meier, John McHugh, Eric Svendsen, James White, Megan Nutzman - and answers their best arguments directly, including a detailed treatment of the celebrated heos hou ("until") case. New in this edition: a full response to Brant Pitre's recent argument that calling Joseph an anēr proves he was a young man.But you do not need Greek, Latin, or a seminary degree. Every foreign word is translated, every technical term explained, every long quotation unpacked in ordinary language. The chapters are short, the tone is warm, and the argument is always easy to follow.For readers on every sideWhether you are Protestant, Catholic, Orthodox, or simply curious about Christian origins, this book gives you the whole picture - the biblical data, the historical record, and the honest state of the question - so you can reach your own conclusion.Includes appendices with a complete translation of the Protevangelium of James, chronologies, family trees, Orthodox liturgical texts, and J. B. Lightfoot's classic essay "The Brethren of the Lord."